Order Now!

Delivery Pickup

YOUR PIE Pizza Restaurant St. Augustine | Palencia
389 Paseo Reyes Dr St. Augustine, FL

Hours of Operation

Monday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Tuesday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Wednesday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Thursday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Friday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Saturday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Sunday

11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

July 4th

12:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Amenities

Dine-in
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
High Chairs
Curbside Pickup
Takeout
Craft Beer
Kid Friendly

ORDER DELIVERY

Delivered To You!

ORDER PICKUP

Curbside Or In-store

CALL NOW

Give us a call

GET DIRECTIONS

Come and see us

LEAVE A REVIEW

Tell us about your visit

VIEW MENU

Check our offerings

Get Our App & Start Earning Pizza Rewards

Want to skip the line? Download the Your Pie app to order and pay online! Each pizza you order on the app earns you special rewards points and alerts you to deals and upcoming events.

Earn Free Pizza!

Earn Free Pizza!

Get Loyalty Rewards when you use the app.

Track Your Rewards!

Track Your Rewards!

Check your points and redeem for offers.

Your Pie Pizza Restaurant - St. Augustine | Palencia Reviews

  • Great price and great food. The kids really enjoyed it all.

  • Had a late business lunch there today. Gentleman who took our order and made our pies was nice and thorough with our requests. Accommodated special requests and last minute "Ooooh, add ____" with grace and good spirit. Also... As always in my reviews... Beer temp. Beer was cold. Had a Kona Golden Ale in the can. Good meal!

  • Good pizza that can be customized in front of you like Subway sandwiches. Nice fresh ingredients with healthier options including whole wheat crust and cauliflower crust. Not the most expensive nor the cheapest. Glad they are here and convenient!

  • Great food, great service. Very friendly and efficient staff. I come here weekly and always have an outstanding experience. Will definitely be back again.

Your Pie Pizza Catering - Let us cater your next event!

Nothing says catering like Your Pie! Delicious paninis, pizza, and cheesy bread that will liven up any get-together. Check out our catering-specific menu and get ideas for Your Event!

YOUR PIE PIZZA IN St. Augustine | Palencia

The oven is fired up near the beaches of St. Augustine. Your Pie Pizza in St Augustine is open now on Paseo Reyes Dr, near U.S. Hwy 1, to serve delicious pizzas to the St. Augustine community. Located near Palencia Park and the Tolomato River, we can serve gorgeous views alongside our pizza. Stop by our St. Augustine pizza restaurant for a bite to eat before an outdoor adventure or during a road trip along the coast.

Your Pie makes everyday moments better with pizza!

Visit Your Pie Pizza Restaurant in St. Augustine

We love being able to serve personal-sized, custom pizzas to the community with ingredients that are always fresh. Your Pie offers build your own brick oven pizza for dine in, delivery, carry out, or catering. Earn free pizza with our rewards app. Vegan, gluten-free, & keto available. Pizzas, pastas, & gelato.

In addition to serving great pizza, part of our mission is to support our local communities through percentage nights and other fun giveback events. We’re open now, so stop by and tell us about the local causes you care about most. We would love the opportunity to support them! As much as we love pizza, we love the communities we serve even more. Your Pie Pizza restaurant in St. Augustine is also a great place to dine with friends and family.

At Your Pie, we make all of our pizzas with hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, homemade sauces and homemade salad dressings. High-quality ingredients and fresh toppings are part of what makes our pizza so delicious. We can also accommodate individuals with dietary restrictions or preferences with our gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan and vegetarian pizza options. If you have any concerns regarding the preparation of your meal, don’t hesitate to talk with one of our team members.

Want to skip the line? Download the Your Pie app to order and pay online! Each pizza you order on the app earns you special rewards points and alerts you to deals and upcoming events. Don’t forget to like our Facebook page to stay in the know on all of our upcoming events. We are thrilled to serve up the best pizza St. Augustine has ever tasted!

We are now offering large 14″ pizzas with online orders. If you are looking for craft beer, vegetarian, gluten free, vegan, or traditional pizza, Your Pie Pizza of St. Augustine Palencia has you covered. We provide pizza takeout, delivery, and dine-in as a lunch restaurant and dinner restaurant.

PIZZA TAKEOUT AND PIZZA DELIVERY IN ST. AUGUSTINE, FL

Your Pie Pizza isn’t just a sit-down dinner or lunch restaurant. We have plenty of options so that you can enjoy our delicious pizza on your busy schedule. Order pizza takeout and watch our team cook your pizza to perfection in our signature brick oven. You can even enjoy a glass of wine or craft beer while you wait for your pizza takeout! Call now or click here to order and we will have your specialty pizza ready to go when you arrive.

And if you don’t have time for pizza takeout, pizza delivery is always an option. Order online or call our pizza restaurant to begin your order. Your pizza will be delivered right to your door. Your Pie Pizza in St. Augustine offers pizza delivery so you don’t have to leave your home or office. We offer personal-sized pizzas and large pizzas for delivery. Click here for pizza delivery from our St. Augustine location.

CRAFT BEER RESTAURANT IN ST. AUGUSTINE, FL

If you plan on enjoying our dinner restaurant, take note of the fact that we are also a craft beer restaurant in St Augustine FL. We serve a carefully-selected, seasonal rotation of craft beer on tap. Choose a local favorite or find something new to try from a brewery near you. Craft beer and pizza are a great combination we can’t wait for you to enjoy at our pizza restaurant. Feel free to call ahead to hear the currently available craft beer beer options at our St. Augustine pizza restaurant.

VEGETARIAN AND VEGAN RESTAURANT IN ST. AUGUSTINE, FL

Unlike other pizza restaurants in St Augustine Palencia, Your Pie Pizza is also a vegetarian and vegan restaurant. We’re excited to offer a wide selection of toppings you can combine to your satisfaction. Create a perfectly balanced veggie pizza pie! Besides veggie options, we also offer Daiya vegan cheese to create a completely vegan pizza. Whether you are looking to try new food or accommodate a dietary restriction, Your Pie Pizza restaurant is here for you.

GLUTEN-FREE RESTAURANT IN ST. AUGUSTINE, FL

Because pizza crust is made of flour, many gluten-free or gluten-sensitive individuals struggle to find something they will enjoy at pizza restaurants. Here at Your Pie Pizza in St Augustine FL, we have just the solution for you! Our gluten-free cauliflower crust makes the perfect base for a gluten-free pie. You can let our team know about your dietary restrictions, and we will do everything to prevent cross-contamination with gluten products. Just let us know if you have any questions or require anything so that your pizza will turn out exactly how you want!

Pizza Restaurant

St. Augustine Healthy Pizza Options

St. Augustine Your Pie offers various health-conscious options to accommodate vegan, KETO, and gluten-free lifestyles! Try our KETO-friendly cauliflower pie crust to build your own low-carb or craft style pizza! Daiya vegan cheese paired with vegan white, wheat, or gluten-free crust creates a delicious foundation for a plant-based pie. Make it a combo with a zero calorie drink and finish it off with a yummy fat-free, non-dairy sorbet!

Pizza Restaurant

St. Augustine Kid’s Meals with Gelato

Our family-focused restaurant creates an enjoyable atmosphere for you and your children. Kids under 12 years can choose from a 7″ pizza, half panini, or side salad, served with a 12 ounce drink and a scoop of yummy gelato – an Italian frozen dessert made with milk instead of cream, extracting its delectable sweetness from rich-in-flavor all-natural ingredients instead of butterfat, making it a healthier alternative to ice cream at 93% fat-free.

Pizza Restaurant

St. Augustine Build Your Own Pizza

In addition to our classic craft series pies, you have the option to build your own pizza from our hand-tossed traditional dough, house-made sauces, cheese, fresh toppings, and wide range of protein options. Personalize a bare-bones or fully loaded pie without being nickeled and dimed for every topping. Once your masterpiece is complete, we bake to order in our fiery brick oven for a crispy, melty, and ready-to-serve pizza!

We're "INSPIERING" COMMUNITIES

We are passionate people committed to making a difference in the communities we serve.

GET PLUGGED IN

See What's Happening on Facebook for Your Pie Pizza Restaurant in St. Augustine | Palencia

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons

1 day ago

Your Pie

Everyone knows pasta is pizza's first cousin.

And we love her dearly! Stop by your local Your Pie today and grab a bowl (available with vegan cheese)! 🍝 yourpie.olo.com
... See MoreSee Less

Everyone knows pasta is pizzas first cousin. 

And we love her dearly! Stop by your local Your Pie today and grab a bowl (available with vegan cheese)! 🍝 yourpie.olo.com

3 days ago

Your Pie

Your Pie is a place where everyone can slow down, gather round the table and share delicious food with the ones we love. This ritual is what life is all about.

Happy Thanksgiving from our family table to yours. ❤️🍕
... See MoreSee Less

Your Pie is a place where everyone can slow down, gather round the table and share delicious food with the ones we love. This ritual is what life is all about.

Happy Thanksgiving from our family table to yours. ❤️🍕

5 days ago

Your Pie

We took a survey and the results are in: the best part of ordering a Large Pizza is that no one knows it's not for sharing. 🤭

Try the large Spicy Italian Pizza today and see if you can handle the heat! 🔥 yourpie.olo.com
... See MoreSee Less

Load more

Join Our Team

Looking for a great career opportunity? Join the Your Pie Family! Click the button below and apply now.

Now Hiring Restaurant Team Members