YOUR PIE Pizza Restaurant Fleming Island
1545 County Road 220 Fleming Island, FL

Visit Your Pie Pizza Restaurant in Fleming Island

In addition to serving great pizza, part of our mission is to support our local communities through percentage nights and other fun giveback events. Stop by and tell us about the local causes you care about most. We would love the opportunity to support them! As much as we love pizza, we love the communities we serve even more.

At Your Pie, we make all of our pizzas with hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, homemade sauces and homemade salad dressings. High-quality ingredients and fresh toppings are part of what makes our pizza so delicious. We can also accommodate individuals with dietary restrictions or preferences with our gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan and vegetarian menu offerings. If you have any concerns regarding the preparation of your meal, don’t hesitate to talk with one of our team members.

Want to skip the line? Download the Your Pie app to order and pay online! Each pizza you order on the app earns you special rewards points and alerts you to deals and upcoming events. Don’t forget to like our Facebook page to stay in the know on all of our upcoming events. We are excited for the opportunity to serve the best pizza in Fleming Island!

We’ve been a part of the island community for more than four years now and we invite you to stop by any day of the week for great food and hospitality served up by our friendly staff. If you can’t decide, we are happy to help with suggestions – we love our food too!

We team up frequently with New Vision Cinemas throughout the year for movie promotions and premieres in the theater two blocks away as well as in our store. Stop by for a quick lunch or dinner on your way!

Your Pie Fleming Island

Here at Your Pie Fleming Island, we work hard to serve the Fleming Island community delicious pizza with a smile and warm greeting! Great food is only part of our business, great service is even more important to us! Getting great reviews like this is what it’s all about:  

“Let me tell you why we are a YOUR PIE family for life. We have been coming to YOUR PIE for almost 2 years. (We used to go once every two weeks). Recently, they were experiencing some cooking issues that didn’t seem like they were going to be resolved. We happened to post something on social media about how sad we were that this was happening. We were contacted and told to call the owner. Between the wonderful response from the owner and managers, our deep-rooted love for the place and food and the correction of our complaint… We are in for the long haul! They are a great example of the fact that businesses don’t have to be perfect… But a heartfelt response to a stumble makes ALL THE DIFFERENCE! We are so happy to put them back on our favorites list!!!!” -Tasley Wheeler

What should you order on your next visit? Here are a few of our favorite pizza Fleming Island flavors!

Southern Heat: buffalo sauce, mozzarella, chicken, red onions, and jalapenos. Add some bacon for an extra flavor boost!

Ischia: extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and garlic

Lineage: marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers.

If you’re in the Orange Park or Fleming Island area, please join us each week on:

MONDAYS – KIDS MEALS ONLY $3.14 ALL DAY
Whether traditional school days or virtual learning is the plan for your family this semester, enjoy family time together and great food on Mondays at YOUR PIE! Children 12 and under receive one (1) Kids Meal at only $3.14 (includes 7? cheese or pepperoni pizza, Kids beverage and a Kids gelato) with the purchase of each adult meal.

TUESDAYS – DOUBLE POINTS DAY
Order through the YOUR PIE App or scan your receipt to earn double points on any purchase you make (excluding tax & tip) every Tuesday through the end of 2022!

THURSDAYS – WEEKLY GROUP RUN/WALK
Plan to meet up with your friends, neighbors and other runners and walkers on our back patio for 3.14 miles (a “Pi” K) every Thursday at 6:30 pm! As a reward, YOUR PIE treats participants to a free ice-cold beverage or a scoop of authentic Italian gelato or sorbet afterward. All paces are welcome – strollers too!

To discuss special events or FUN-raisers, please speak with or email our Store Manager at [email protected]!

Craft Beer Restaurant in Fleming Island FL

Your Pie Pizza offers much more than just pizza. Did you know our lunch and dinner restaurant is also a craft beer restaurant in Fleming Island FL? That means we serve a delicious and refreshing rotation of beers on tap for you. Enjoy one of your local favorites or find something new to try from a beer brewery near you. Pizza and beer is a classic combination we can’t wait for you to try at our pizza restaurant. You can even enjoy a craft beer while you wait for your pizza to be ready for takeout or delivery. Our pizza restaurant also offers wine by the glass or bottle. Enjoy a relaxing evening at Your Pie Pizza dinner restaurant after work or a long day of errands.

Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant in Fleming Island FL

There aren’t a lot of restaurants in Fleming that offer delicious and filling comfort meals like pizza and pasta while also remaining vegetarian restaurants with gluten-free offerings. Enjoy a fresh veggie pizza with our various vegetarian toppings. Open now, our pizza restaurant prides itself on letting pizza be whatever it means to you. You no longer have to feel left out when you’re out to dinner with friends and family. Tomatoes, olives, spinach, onions, mushrooms, or a combination of all of the above — the choices are all yours. This vegetarian restaurant is open now for lunch or dinner, so don’t miss out.