You can, but here’s some advice from our founder Drew and the culinary team: You’re not limited, but we recommend selecting your favorite five or six toppings for your pizza or panini. Limiting the number of toppings ensures your pizza or panini will be cooked correctly, which is part of what makes Your Pie super delicious. You also have the option to add more than once sauce or cheese if you’d like! Try adding garlic or oregano for extra flavor, too.